Elders of Antioch Presbyterian Church, 1843-Present

• Robert Blakely: August, 17, 1843 – December 17, 2860
• William Leonard: August 17, 1843 – August 31, 1855
• John Anderson: August 17, 1843 – March 5, 1878
• A. C. Jackson: June 16, 1850 – 1856
• James Templeton: August 19, 1855 – January 28, 1857
• James Anderson: August 15, 1857 – May 12, 1883
• Andrew Coan: May 5, 1864 – March 6, 1899
• Amzi W. Gaston: August 25, 1872 – June 26, 1904
• George B. Anderson: August 25, 1872 – November 16, 1884
• Dr. A. J. Creighton: September 17, 1876 – June 14, 1890
• Dr. W. A. Harrison: March 16, 1884 – November 15, 1890
• Frank L. Anderson: March 16, 1884 – June 26, 1904
• Morton L. Venable: October 17, 1886 – October 16, 1887
• S. R. Gresham: March 15, 1890 – June 26, 1904
• James W. Darby: August 20, 1893 – June 26, 1904
• D. B. Simpson: October 18, 1896 – September 25, 1900
• J. W. Wilson: September 16, 1900 – June 26, 1904
• William P. Fowler: September 4, 1904 – ??
• Joseph Stanley Kilgore, Sr.: July 3, 1904 – March 2, 1921
• John T. Dillard: July 2, 1905 – ??
• N. Pierce Anderson: June 20, 1909 – November 28, 1944
• Norton R. Gaston: December 7, 1914 – August 16, 1925
• Lorraine Leonard: February 17, 1918 – August 25, 1981
• Wells B. Kilgore: Mary 5, 1923 – July 5, 1950
• J. T. Hayes: November 8, 1925 – May 9, 1926
• Joe H. Kilgore: November 8, 1925 – February 10, 1974
• Agnew W. Leonard: December 10, 1933 – May 8, 1973
• Edd J. Johnson: May 5, 1946 – February 6, 1965
• William H. Johnson: April 29, 1951 – November 3, 1981 (Elder Emeritus to January 7, 1982)
• Grady Kemp: April 29, 1951 – March 6, 1955
• J. Daniel Kilgore: April 29, 1951 – February 14, 1986
• James Hudson: April 9, 1967 – January 28, 1984
• Joe H. Kilgore, Jr.: March 10, 1974 – July 28, 1985
• Harold D. Leonard: March 10, 1974 – October 2, 1976
• T. Mack Carlton: January 28, 1977 – ??
• V. Reid Hudson: April 4, 1982 – 1985 (Elder Emeritus to ??)
• James Brown: April 4, 1982 – February 23, 2020 (Elder Emeritus)
• Philip Malphrus: April 4, 1982 – July 10, 1985
• John S. Hassell: May 11, 1986 – ??
• William A. Leonard: May 11, 1986 – ??
• A. William Leonard: January 24, 1993 – ??
• Dr. Chipley Bennett: July 25, 2020 – Present (Provisional RE; Providence PCA)
• Dr. E. Todd Buchner: July 25, 2020 – Present (Provisional TE; Reidville PCA)
• Richard Hollifield: July 25, 2020 – Present (Provisional RE; Roebuck PCA)
• William Johnson: July 25, 2020 – Present (Provisional RE; Woodruff Road PCA)
• Richard Thomas: July 25, 2020 – October 28, 2021 (Provisional TE; Mount Calvary PCA) 
• W. Tosh Groce: April 22, 2021 – July 23, 2022 (Provisional RE; Blue Ridge PCA)
• Theodore “Terry” Richards: July 23, 2022 – Present (Provisional RE; Fellowship PCA)